Electoral college criticism

But there are also staunch defenders of the Electoral College who, though perhaps less vocal than its critics, offer very powerful arguments in its favor. Arguments Against the Electoral College Those who object to the Electoral College system and favor a direct popular election of the president generally do so on four grounds:

Electoral college criticism

Today, far from being considered perfect or excellent, the Electoral College is criticized for being somehow undemocratic. Is this criticism justified?

Ashland University Professor David Foster addresses that criticism. Presidential elections often prompt criticism of the system we use to appoint a chief executive.

10 reasons why the Electoral College is a problem | MinnPost

For if re-election Electoral college criticism on a known body of men — a legislature, for example — the president might sacrifice his duty to please that body. Thus, the method described in the Constitution aims at a calm, thoughtful choice unaffected by domestic disorder and the machinations of foreign governments.

At the same time, because it is intended to combine dependence on the people of America with meaningful input from those with a deep knowledge of politics, it aims at a wise choice the people will support.

In Federalist 68, Hamilton explains how all these advantages, discussed apparently in ascending order of importance, are achieved through the system of electors. The Jefferson-Burr deadlock of revealed the problem of having electors make two votes without distinguishing President and Vice-President.

Electoral college criticism

Other oversights were remedied in the 20th and 25th Amendmentsbut none of these changes fundamentally altered the system. Despite the great transformation in the country sincethe Electoral College system has proved remarkably flexible and stable, delivering appointments that have been widely accepted as legitimate by the American people for two and a quarter centuries.

I just felt that you could never replicate the classroom experience.

50 Documents That Tell America’s Story

With a broadband internet connection, an ordinary computer or laptop, and a standard web browser, students and the instructor can see and hear one another, live and in real time.

There is lots of back and forth dialogue. Sikkenga, about his recent Live Online course on the Supreme Court. Technological glitches are rare.

The Supreme Court has profoundly affected the course of American history, yet few citizens understand how it operates.

Electoral college criticism

Teachers need a clear understanding, since important moments in American history are often heralded by Supreme Court decisions. Some textbooks cover this decision in a way that is not very accurate; others in a way that is accurate but incomplete.

The average citizen reacts to a Supreme Court decision as he would to a legislative or executive action, measuring it against his own sense of fairness. But the Court measures the law against the Constitution. It is important to understand how this works, though. Their job is to decide legal cases that come before them.

There are lots of other courts around the world who assess the constitutionality of law before it is passed. The Court assesses the constitutionality of laws after citizens and communities have already lived with it in practice.

Board of Education, the Court overturned an understanding of the Fourteenth Amendment that had been in place since the ruling in Plessy v. Ferguson and after intervening decades of Jim Crow laws and practices.

Politics play a role at times, as justices decide which cases to hear. Aware of their constitutionally restricted authority, justices have learned to avoid rulings that carry an appearance of bias. The Court thought it was settling the slavery problem for the US once and for all, but in fact it did the opposite, because a huge percentage of the American people thought its decision was purely political.

Courses are live and online — no boring recorded lectures, and no assignments that you complete anonymously and send to a professor you never see. Courses are condensed and conveniently scheduled so you can earn two graduate credits in just eight weeks! Our Spring schedule will be announced soon!

Watch your e-mail for the announcement. These seminars are on Saturday mornings throughout the fall and spring semesters. Seminars are designed to give teachers the opportunity to learn about and discuss important topics and texts in American history and government with nationally recognized scholars and teachers.

If you have a computer with a standard web browser and a broadband internet connection, participation is as simple as clicking on a link; WebEx Training Center will take care of the rest. Gordon Lloyd Pepperdine University For more information, or to register, click here.

Delivered live via the WebEx web conference platform, your students can learn from leading scholars in US history and government. You and your students can see, hear, and speak to our professors live and online. Each webinar investigates key themes in American history and government.

For more information about the program or to apply to host a webinar in your classroom, click here. Constitution Booklets Available The Ashbrook Center offers a pocket-sized booklet that holds key texts of the American founding, including the Declaration of Independence and the entire text of the US Constitution and its amendments, as well as key primary texts interpreting these.

Expert Answers

These convenient booklets make excellent classroom resources for American history, civics, and government classes. Special bulk pricing is available for quantities of 10, 25, or more.The Electoral College may have made sense when it was created, because counting votes and transmitting that information quickly and securely were very difficult tasks in the 18th century.

The electoral college is supposed to go against the will of the people if they believe that the winning candidate is unfit for the office of the Presidency. They are . Views on the Electoral College are often partisan The winner-take-all system explains why one candidate can get more votes nationwide while a different candidate wins in Electoral College.

Oct 25,  · What are Some Criticisms of the Electoral College? The White House, home of the president of the United States, who is chosen by the Electoral College. The Electoral College is the number of votes which determines the outcomes of a US presidential race.

The electoral college is supposed to go against the will of the people if they believe that the winning candidate is unfit for the office of the Presidency. They are supposed to be able to vote against what the people want.

And the Electoral College was designed to represent each State's choice for the presidency (with the number of each State's electoral votes being the number of its Senators plus the number of its Representatives).

The Electoral College - Pros and Cons